FHF Gear 24HR Satchel vs WaterField Designs Shinjuku Tote
The FHF Gear 24HR Satchel is 17L and 0.65kg1.4lb; the WaterField Designs Shinjuku Tote is 16L and 0.68kg1.5lb. The FHF Gear 24HR Satchel is 0.03kg0.1lb lighter. The FHF Gear 24HR Satchel costs $74 less. The FHF Gear 24HR Satchel fits the carry-on limit of 36 of 36 major airlines and the WaterField Designs Shinjuku Tote fits 36; under the seat, 14 and 10 of 26.
| Spec | FHF Gear 24HR Satchel | WaterField Designs Shinjuku Tote |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $175Best | $249 |
| Volume | 17L | 16L |
| Weight | 0.65kg1.4lbBest | 0.68kg1.5lb |
| Carry-on compliance | 100% | 100% |
| Personal-item compliance | 54%Best | 38% |
| Dimensions | 27.9×39.4×15.2cm11×15.5×6in | 33×38.1×12.7cm13×15×5in |
| Laptop | sleeve, size not published | no laptop sleeve |
| Bottle pockets | n/a | 2 |
| Opening | n/a | magnetic top closure, zippered front pocket, magnetic back pocket |
| Warranty | No fixed term | Lifetime |
| Organizer | Yes | Yes |
| Shoe compartment | No | No |
| Hydration sleeve | No | No |
| Frame sheet | No | No |
| Water-resistant | No | No |
| Rain cover | No | No |
| MOLLE | Yes | No |
| Hip belt | No | No |
| Sternum strap | No | No |
| Load lifters | No | No |
| Shoulder strap | Yes | No |
| Luggage pass-through | No | Yes |
| Camera compartment | No | No |
| Material | ECOPAK laminate, YKK Aquaguard zips, laser-cut Squadron laminate | 15 oz waxed canvas or 1680D ballistic nylon, full-grain leather accents |
| Last checked | 2026-10 | 2026-10 |
Where their airline fit differs
| Airline | Limit | FHF Gear 24HR Satchel | WaterField Designs Shinjuku Tote |
|---|---|---|---|
| ANA (All Nippon Airways) | Personal item | Fits | Too big |
| Norwegian Air Shuttle | Personal item | Fits | Too big |
| Ryanair | Personal item | Fits | Too big |
| Vueling | Personal item | Fits | Too big |
| WestJet | Personal item | Too big | Fits |
| Wizz Air | Personal item | Fits | Too big |
Add more bags to this comparison
Specs come from each brand's own product page. Fit uses listed dimensions in any orientation. How we score carry-on fit.